Top 5 Most Valuable 49ers Football Cards of All Time

October 28, 2023
5
min read

Top 5 Most Valuable San Francisco 49ers Football Cards of All Time

The San Francisco 49ers are one of the most successful franchises in NFL history. With 5 Super Bowl wins and players like Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, and Steve Young, it's no wonder 49ers cards are some of the most sought after by collectors. Let's take a look at the top 5 most valuable 49ers football cards of all time.

1. Joe Montana 1981 Topps #216 Rookie Card

As one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, Joe Montana cards carry a lot of value. His 1981 Topps rookie is considered his premier rookie card and is the most sought after of his early cards. Here's a quick rundown on the 1981 Topps #216 Montana:

  • Features Montana in his #16 jersey getting ready to pass
  • Part of the 1981 Topps football set
  • One of Montana's first NFL cards

This iconic rookie card routinely sells for $600-$1,000 or more depending on condition. Gem mint copies (PSA 10 grade) have sold for as much as $7,800 at auction. Not bad for a basic 1981 Topps card!

2. Jerry Rice 1986 Topps #161 Rookie Card

Widely considered the best wide receiver to ever play in the NFL, Jerry Rice won 3 Super Bowls with the 49ers and every major receiving record during his 20 seasons. His key rookie card is also one of the top 49ers cards:

  • 1986 Topps #161 features a close up shot of Rice
  • Part of the legendary 1986 Topps football set
  • One of Rice's first NFL trading cards

Mint copies of the Rice rookie can sell for $350-$500 for PSA 9's and up to $2,500 for perfect PSA 10 examples. It's the must-own Rice card for 49ers collectors.

3. Steve Young 1991 Pro Set #456

Although later in his career, Steve Young cards can be extremely popular as well. Arguably his most valuable is his 1991 Pro Set card:

  • Shows Young dropping back to pass in his #8 jersey
  • Part of the 1991 Pro Set NFL set
  • Some of Young's earliest 49ers cards as Montana's backup

This Pro Set Young can sell for around $125-$200 in PSA 10 condition. Lower grade copies still sell for $20-$50. While not as pricey as Montana and Rice's rookies, it's still one of the best Young cards to own.

4. Dwight Clark 1981 Topps #385 Rookie Card

Dwight Clark is responsible for "The Catch" - one of the most famous plays in 49ers history. As part of the 1981 championship team, his rookie cards are also hot collectibles:

  • 1981 Topps #385 features Clark running with the ball
  • Included in the '81 Topps set
  • First NFL card for Clark as a rookie

Mint copies of Clark's rookie top out around $60-$100 for graded PSA 10's. Even well-worn copies can sell for $10-$20. It's the premier Dwight Clark card for any serious 49ers collector.

5. Ronnie Lott 1981 Topps #216 Rookie Card

Rounding out our top 5 is a Hall of Fame defensive back - Ronnie Lott. Lott won 4 Super Bowls with the 49ers and was known for his hard-hitting style of play. His key rookie is another 1981 Topps card:

  • Card #434 in the '81 set
  • Depicts Lott in his #42 jersey warming up
  • One of Lott's first football cards as a rookie

This iconic rookie sells for around $50-$100 in top graded condition. Lesser copies still carry a $10-$25 price tag. It's the must-own Lott card for 49ers fans.

There you have it - the top 5 most valuable San Francisco 49ers football cards of all time! From Montana to Rice to Lott, these cards represent Hall of Fame players that led the 49ers through a dominant period of Super Bowl wins. Owning just one of these cards is a thrill for diehard fans.

Collecting vintage cards of the best players is one of the great joys of the hobby. But remember, condition is king when it comes to value. The difference between a worn out card and one in mint condition can be thousands of dollars. Store your cards properly and get them professionally graded whenever possible.

Building a 49ers collection with any of these gems will ensure you have a valuable representation of the storied franchise. And who knows - you might just own the next six or seven-figure football card! Either way, enjoy chasing the top cards of Montana, Rice, Young, Clark, Lott, and the many other San Francisco greats.

Shop graded 49ers slabs

Related articles

Top Trevor Lawrence Rookie Cards

Top Josh Allen Rookie Cards to Collect

Top 5 Most Valuable Denver Broncos Football Cards of all Time