Submit CardsBUY CARDS

Top 10 Most Valuable Cowboys Football Cards of All Time

Discover the top 10 most valuable Dallas Cowboys football cards, spanning decades and featuring iconic players that captivate collectors.
December 14, 2023
3
min read

Introduction

 Welcome, sports memorabilia enthusiasts and football fanatics alike! We're about to embark on a thrilling journey through the annals of Cowboys' history, one trading card at a time. Now, we're not just talking about any old cards. No siree, we're diving deep into the heart of the most valuable Cowboys football cards of all time.

These aren't just pieces of cardboard with pictures slapped on them. They're tangible pieces of history, capturing iconic moments and legendary players from one of the most storied franchises in the NFL. From the golden era of Roger Staubach to the modern-day exploits of Dak Prescott, these cards encapsulate the essence of the Cowboys' spirit.

So, whether you're a die-hard Cowboys fan, a dedicated card collector, or simply a sports enthusiast with a penchant for nostalgia, this list is for you. Buckle up and get ready for a wild ride through gridiron history, as we count down the top 10 most valuable Cowboys football cards of all time. Trust us, you won't want to miss a beat!

The History of Cowboys Football Cards

 Ever since the dawn of American football, trading cards have been a cherished part of the sport's culture. Cowboys football cards, in particular, hold a special place in the hearts of fans and collectors alike. These small pieces of cardboard, emblazoned with the faces of our gridiron heroes, have been around since the team's inception in 1960.

The first set of Cowboys cards, released by the Topps Company, featured the team's inaugural roster. Over the years, these cards have evolved, mirroring the team's ups and downs, triumphs and tribulations. They've become more than just collectibles - they're a tangible piece of Cowboys history.

From the iconic 1962 Bob Lilly rookie card to the coveted 1989 Troy Aikman card, these collectibles have captured the essence of the Cowboys' legacy. They're not just pieces of cardboard, they're snapshots of gridiron greatness. So, saddle up as we take a trip down memory lane, exploring the top 10 most valuable Cowboys football cards of all time.

Factors Determining the Value of Cowboys Football Cards

 When it comes to determining the value of Cowboys football cards, several factors come into play. First and foremost, the player featured on the card is a big deal. Cards of Hall of Famers or popular players like Troy Aikman or Emmitt Smith are worth their weight in gold.

Secondly, the condition of the card is paramount. A mint condition card can fetch a pretty penny, while a card with a bent corner or a crease might not be worth the paper it's printed on.

Thirdly, the rarity of the card can significantly influence its value. Limited edition or short print cards are often more valuable than their common counterparts.

Fourthly, the year the card was issued can also affect its worth. Vintage cards, especially those from the Cowboys' early years, are typically more sought after by collectors.

Lastly, the card's grading by a reputable company like PSA or Beckett can dramatically increase its value. A high-grade card is a real treasure in the collecting world.

In a nutshell, if you're looking to cash in on your Cowboys football cards, keep an eye on the player, condition, rarity, year, and grading. These are the key factors that can turn your card collection into a gold mine.

1. 1998 Peyton Manning Playoff Contenders Ticket

 Taking the top spot on our list, the 1998 Peyton Manning Playoff Contenders Ticket is, without a shadow of a doubt, the most valuable Cowboys football card of all time. This card is a true gem, a rare find that would make any collector's heart skip a beat.

Now, you might be wondering, what makes this card so special? Well, for starters, it features Peyton Manning, one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. But that's not all. This card is part of the Playoff Contenders series, a highly sought-after collection among card enthusiasts.

Moreover, the 1998 edition is particularly rare, making it even more valuable. It's like finding a needle in a haystack! If you're lucky enough to get your hands on this card, you're sitting on a gold mine.

In a nutshell, the 1998 Peyton Manning Playoff Contenders Ticket is the Holy Grail of Cowboys football cards. It's a must-have for any serious collector.

2. 1989 Troy Aikman Score Football Rookie Card

 Let's mosey on down memory lane to the year 1989, when a young buck named Troy Aikman was just starting his illustrious career with the Dallas Cowboys. His Score Football Rookie Card, issued that same year, is a true gem in any collection.

Why, you ask? Well, it's simple. Aikman's rookie card is a testament to his legendary status in the NFL. It's like owning a piece of history, a snapshot of a time when a star was born.

This card showcases Aikman in his prime, donning the iconic Cowboys' silver and blue. It's a sight for sore eyes, especially for die-hard Cowboys fans.

Now, let's talk numbers. Depending on its condition, this card can fetch a pretty penny. In mint condition, it's worth around $200. But, if you're lucky enough to own a gem mint 10, you could be looking at a price tag upwards of $1,000.

So, if you've got this card tucked away somewhere, it might be time to dust it off and give it the appreciation it deserves. After all, it's not every day you come across the second most valuable Cowboys football card of all time.

3. 1965 Joe Namath Topps Rookie Card

 Ah, the '65 Joe Namath Topps Rookie Card, a real gem in the world of Cowboys football cards. This card is a sight for sore eyes, boasting a classic design that's as timeless as the man himself. It's the rookie card of Broadway Joe, one of the most iconic figures in NFL history.

The card captures Namath in his prime, a young buck ready to take the football world by storm. It's a snapshot of a moment in time, a piece of history encapsulated in a small piece of cardboard.

But it's not just the nostalgia factor that makes this card valuable. It's also quite rare, especially in top condition. Most of these cards have been through the wringer, making mint condition examples a hot commodity.

So, if you're lucky enough to have one of these in your collection, hold onto it. It's one of the most valuable Cowboys football cards out there, and its value is only going up.

4. 1991 Brett Favre Stadium Club Rookie Card

 Ah, the '91 Brett Favre Stadium Club Rookie Card - a true gem in the realm of Cowboys football cards. This card, my friends, is the epitome of a diamond in the rough. Now, you might be scratching your head, thinking, "Wait a minute, isn't Brett Favre a Packers legend?" Well, you're not wrong. However, Favre was initially drafted by the Atlanta Falcons, and this card captures him in his rookie year, before he donned the Packers' green and gold.

What makes this card a valuable collectible? Well, it's all about scarcity and demand. This card isn't as common as some others, making it a rare find. Plus, Favre's legendary status boosts its appeal. It's a snapshot of history, capturing a future star before his rise to fame. So, if you're lucky enough to have this card in your collection, hold onto it. Its value is only going to climb higher.

5. 2000 Tom Brady Bowman Chrome Rookie Card

 Get a load of this! The 2000 Tom Brady Bowman Chrome Rookie Card is a gem that's not to be overlooked. Now, I know what you're thinking, "Isn't Brady a Patriot?" Well, you're not wrong. However, his immense influence on the game has made his rookie card a valuable asset for any collector.

This card, in mint condition, is a sight for sore eyes. It features a young Brady, fresh-faced and ready to take on the world. The card's design is sleek and modern, with a shiny chrome finish that adds a touch of class.

Here's the kicker, the card's value has skyrocketed in recent years. In 2020, a gem mint version of this card sold for a whopping $250,000! So, if you're lucky enough to have this card in your collection, you're sitting on a gold mine.

In a nutshell, the 2000 Tom Brady Bowman Chrome Rookie Card is a must-have for any serious Cowboys card collector. It's a testament to Brady's legacy and a piece of football history.

6. 1986 Jerry Rice Topps Rookie Card

 Get a load of this one, folks! The 1986 Jerry Rice Topps Rookie Card is a true gem in the world of Cowboys football cards. This card features the legendary wide receiver, Jerry Rice, in his rookie year. It's a snapshot of history, capturing the moment when Rice was just starting to make waves in the NFL.

Now, let's talk turkey. The value of this card has skyrocketed over the years, thanks to Rice's stellar career and the card's limited availability. It's not uncommon for this card to fetch prices in the thousands, especially if it's in mint condition.

But here's the kicker: the 1986 Jerry Rice Topps Rookie Card isn't just a valuable piece of memorabilia. It's a testament to Rice's skill and dedication, a reminder of his incredible career, and a must-have for any serious Cowboys card collector. So if you're lucky enough to get your hands on one, hold onto it tight!

7. 1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card

 Let's saddle up and ride back to the 80s, where we'll find the 1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card. This card is a real gem in the world of Cowboys football cards, a true testament to Montana's legendary status.

Now, you might be thinking, "Why is this card so valuable?" Well, the answer lies in Montana's illustrious career. He was the man who could turn the tide of a game with a single throw, a real game-changer. His card, therefore, holds a special place in the hearts of collectors.

This card, with its classic 80s design and crisp image of a young Montana, is a must-have for any serious collector. It's like owning a piece of football history. But remember, condition is king. A mint condition card can fetch a pretty penny, so keep your eyes peeled for this one.

In the grand rodeo of collecting, the 1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card is one bronco worth riding!

8. 1958 Jim Brown Topps Rookie Card

 Let's take a trip down memory lane, back to 1958, when the Jim Brown Topps Rookie Card made its grand debut. This card, folks, is a real gem in the world of Cowboys football cards. It's like finding a needle in a haystack, a true rarity.

Why, you ask? Well, it's all about the man himself, Jim Brown. He was a force to be reckoned with on the field, a real game-changer. His rookie card captures the essence of his raw talent and undeniable charisma.

Now, let's talk numbers. This card, in mint condition, can fetch a pretty penny. We're talking upwards of $20,000! But hey, you can't put a price on nostalgia, right?

So, if you're lucky enough to have this card in your collection, hold onto it. It's not just a piece of cardboard, it's a piece of history. And who knows? Its value might just skyrocket in the years to come. So, keep your eyes peeled and your wallets ready, collectors!

9. 1984 Dan Marino Topps Rookie Card

 Next up on our list, we're throwing it back to the '80s with the 1984 Dan Marino Topps Rookie Card. This card is a true gem, a blast from the past that's sure to get any collector's heart racing.

Dan Marino, the legendary quarterback, is a household name in the world of football. His rookie card, issued by Topps in 1984, is one of the most sought-after pieces in the industry. It's not just about the man on the card, but the card itself. It's got that classic '80s design, a simple yet striking layout that screams vintage.

The value of this card has been on a steady rise over the years. It's not just a piece of cardboard, but a piece of history. So, if you're lucky enough to have this card in your collection, hold on to it tight. It's a treasure that's only going to become more valuable with time.

10. 1976 Walter Payton Topps Rookie Card

 Let's kick off our top 10 countdown with a bang! The 1976 Walter Payton Topps Rookie Card is a must-have for any serious collector. This card features the legendary running back in his rookie year, making it a piece of football history.

Why is it so valuable, you ask? Well, Walter Payton, also known as 'Sweetness', was one of the most phenomenal players in NFL history. His rookie card, in mint condition, is a rare find. It's like striking gold in the world of card collecting.

Here's the kicker: the value of this card has been steadily increasing over the years. Today, it's worth a pretty penny. If you're lucky enough to have this card in your collection, hold on to it! It's not just a card, it's an investment.

To sum it up, the 1976 Walter Payton Topps Rookie Card is more than just a piece of cardboard. It's a piece of football history, a valuable asset, and a testament to one of the greatest players the game has ever seen.

Conclusion

 Well, folks, we've reached the end zone of our journey through the top 10 most valuable Cowboys football cards of all time. It's been a wild ride, hasn't it?

Just like a Hail Mary pass, these cards have shown us that sometimes, the most unlikely players can turn out to be the most valuable. From the legendary Troy Aikman to the dynamic duo of Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin, these cards are a testament to the Cowboys' rich history and the players who've made it so.

In conclusion, whether you're a die-hard Cowboys fan, a seasoned card collector, or a newbie just dipping your toes into the world of football cards, these top 10 cards are a must-have. They're not just pieces of cardboard, but snapshots of history, capturing iconic moments and legendary players in their prime.

So, what are you waiting for? Saddle up and start your hunt for these treasures. After all, in the wild west of football card collecting, it's every cowboy for himself. Happy collecting, y'all!"

Remember, the value of a card is not just in its monetary worth, but also in the joy and nostalgia it brings. So, keep collecting, keep cherishing, and most importantly, keep enjoying the wonderful world of football cards.

Shop graded Cowboy slabs

Related articles

Top Trevor Lawrence Rookie Cards

Top Josh Allen Rookie Cards to Collect

Top 5 Most Valuable Denver Broncos Football Cards of all Time

Recently Added