Top 5 Undervalued NFL Cards to Collect in 2024

As the 2024 NFL season approaches, smart collectors are on the hunt for undervalued cards that might be hidden gems in the marketplace. Let’s spotlight some of the top undervalued NFL cards that could yield high returns while also enhancing your collection with some dynamic, underappreciated talent.

​

1. Tua Tagovailoa Rookie Cards

​

After overcoming injuries early in his career, Tua Tagovailoa showed flashes of brilliance that have Miami Dolphins fans and card collectors alike paying attention. His on-field performance is improving, making his rookie cards a potential treasure. Look for Tua Tagovailoa rookie cards on the market today, as their value could increase with a strong season in 2024. 

​

Key Card to Watch: 2020 Panini Prizm Tua Tagovailoa RC

​

2. Justin Herbert Rookie Cards

​

While Herbert has already established himself as a top NFL quarterback in a relatively short amount of time, his rookie cards still fly under the radar compared to other greats. As the Los Angeles Chargers continue to build around him, these cards could be primed for substantial jumps in value.

​

Key Card to Watch: 2020 Panini Prizm Justin Herbert RC

​

3. Jerry Jeudy Rookie Cards

​

Jerry Jeudy is becoming a notable receiver for the Denver Broncos, with route-running that has drawn comparisons to some of the best in the league. His potential for breakout games makes his rookie cards relatively underrated and potentially lucrative.

​

Key Card to Watch: 2020 Panini Prizm Jerry Jeudy RC

​

4. Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards

​

Jonathan Taylor has emerged as a premier running back with the Indianapolis Colts. His consistency and standout performances make his rookie cards a valuable addition to any collection. Given the scarcity of elite running back cards, Taylor’s are poised to appreciate.

​

Key Card to Watch: 2020 Panini Prizm Jonathan Taylor RC 

​

5. CeeDee Lamb Rookie Cards

​

As a wide receiver for the Dallas Cowboys, CeeDee Lamb has quickly become a household name among NFL fans. His exciting play style and significant role within a high-profile team make his rookie cards an attractive and undervalued pick.

​

Key Card to Watch: 2020 Panini Prizm CeeDee Lamb RC 

​

Now is a great time to secure these cards while they remain undervalued. Optimizing your collection with these potentials could yield impressive returns as the players continue to elevate their games.

​

Interested in elevating your collection? Explore our exclusive marketplace here.